Essay
Microsoft's Plan B Was Also Microsoft
Last week's Microsoft 365 outage hit more than seventy countries. You can only have a backup where an open standard lets a second provider speak the same language.

Microsoft runs two separate network systems for Microsoft 365, so that when one has trouble, traffic can move to the other. Early on Thursday 12 November, about fifteen hours before everything went down, Teams was moved onto the backup system. It was later moved back onto the main one. The main one also carries Exchange Online, Microsoft’s email. That extra traffic landed on servers running a software change from July with a hidden bug that testing had never caught, because it only showed up on heavier machines. A separate incident the day before had already taken almost 14% of server capacity temporarily offline.
That is Microsoft’s own account, given by its executive Charles Lamanna and reported by VRT. Servers locked up, users were sent to the ones still working, and those locked up too. “Within less than two hours more than 80 percent of our servers were unreachable,” Lamanna wrote.
Microsoft puts the worst of it at about twenty hours. According to NOS, it took a day and a half before the company declared the outage fully over, one of the longest in the company’s history. Businesses and government bodies in more than seventy countries had trouble with email and meetings, and analysts expect the damage to run into billions.
My company wasn’t touched, because we run on the other big provider. I still noticed how fragile it felt. We kept working because a different American giant happened not to fall that week, which is luck, and I wouldn’t want to build a ministry on it.
Microsoft had a plan B, and it was also Microsoft. Redundancy inside one company saves you when a server breaks. When the company itself pushes a bad update to every server it owns, both of its networks share the same fault.
The wrapper I wanted
My first thought was that someone should sell a layer that sits on top of both providers and falls back from one to the other when it fails. My second was that nobody sells it because the providers design their products so it can’t exist.
I asked Gamma, the AI I write with, to check before I wrote that. I was half right. For email the layer exists. Services like Mimecast’s keep an organisation’s email running through their own platform while Microsoft is down. Phone systems have similar products. For Teams chats, shared documents and calendars inside SharePoint there is nothing comparable.
Email travels over open protocols that any provider can speak, so a second company can step in without asking the first for permission. Teams chats and meetings speak only to Teams. In practice you get a backup wherever an open standard lets someone else speak the same language, and nowhere else.
Why nobody runs a second suite

The apps themselves already exist. Soverin, a Dutch email company that has been around for about ten years, manages more than a million mailboxes and sells a Nextcloud-based suite with mail, files, chat and documents for €10 a month per mailbox before VAT. I have never seen it inside a company, though, and much of its business is mail resold by hosting companies and internet providers. The Dutch state is testing its own suite, MijnBureau, built by the Interior Ministry, together with a Linux desktop in four municipalities, Amsterdam among them.
What keeps organisations on one suite is everything that ties the apps together: one login, one admin console, one security system, and now one AI assistant reading across all of it. In May, Britain’s competition authority opened an investigation into what it calls Microsoft’s “business software ecosystem”. Its notice puts Word, Teams, Windows, the Entra identity system, Intune, Defender and Copilot in a single scope, because they “can be carried out in combination with each other”. A rival can copy any one of those pieces. It can’t plug into the rest unless Microsoft lets it.
The objection I take most seriously comes from the Dutch state itself. In February the Finance state secretary told parliament, citing a tax authority study, that there is no fully integrated European alternative to Microsoft 365 yet, and that rolling out MijnBureau at scale in the tax authority is not realistic for now. Microsoft rarely goes down for this long, and a small provider with fewer engineers may go down more often.
That compares one provider with another, though. A small provider that fails takes its own customers down; Microsoft took more than seventy countries. And a backup only has to carry the mail and a meeting for a day and a half. For that it needs a way in, which is much less than rebuilding Microsoft’s whole ecosystem. If organisations could run two providers side by side, a small European one would be useful long before it was good enough to replace the giant.
The law already has the hook
The EU’s Data Act anticipates this. Article 34 covers the “in-parallel use” of cloud services, several at the same time. Article 35 provides for common interoperability standards, written by European standards bodies or adopted by the Commission itself, and under Article 30, providers of services like Microsoft 365 would have twelve months to comply once those specifications are published. As far as I can find, none have been adopted yet.
So the Commission should get them written, for mail, calendars, chat and documents, built on protocols that already exist, so that any provider can sit behind any other. The Netherlands should require its ministries to keep a second provider able to carry their essential communication, and use MijnBureau as that backup before anyone asks it to replace Microsoft.
Last week the outage was an accident. The same dependence would also work for anyone who wanted to switch Europe off on purpose.
Quotes from VRT are translated from Dutch. How I write with Gamma: see About.
Sources
- Wereldwijde storing Microsoft na anderhalve dag opgelost — NOS
- Maanden onopgemerkt, dan plots catastrofaal: Microsoft onthult hoe softwarefout miljoenen gebruikers trof — VRT NWS
- Ensure Office 365 business continuity with Mimecast — Mimecast
- SoSuite — Soverin
- Heijnen: geen Europees alternatief voor M365 — Binnenlands Bestuur
- Gemeenten testen autonome digitale werkplek — VNG
- Regulation (EU) 2023/2854 (Data Act) — EUR-Lex
- Notice of SMS investigation: Microsoft's Business Software Ecosystem — Competition and Markets Authority
- Soverin bereidt bedrijven voor op geleidelijke migratie uit VS-clouds — Emerce